Psychologist or psychiatrist: what each one actually does, for a WorkCover Queensland claim
The psychiatrists' own college sums up the main differences in three lines: psychiatrists are medical doctors, psychiatrists prescribe medication, and psychologists focus on talk therapy. Here's how training, treatment, referrals and registration compare.
If someone has suggested you see a psychiatrist as well as, or instead of, a psychologist, it helps to know the two titles are easy to confuse. The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists (RANZCP) says as much on its Your Health in Mind website: many people get psychiatrists and psychologists confused with each other.
This guide covers what separates the two professions: how each one is trained, what each one does, how you get an appointment, and how to check registration. It deliberately leaves out what WorkCover Queensland funds or approves for either one. For the claim side, what early treatment covers and what it doesn't and the GP referral and work capacity certificate are the places to look.
The three-line version
RANZCP lists three main differences. Psychiatrists are medical doctors, and psychologists are not. Psychiatrists prescribe medication, and psychologists can't. Psychiatrists diagnose illness, manage treatment and provide a range of therapies for complex and serious mental illness, while psychologists focus on providing psychotherapy (talk therapy).
The same page is clear about what they share. Both understand how the brain works, along with emotions, feelings and thoughts, and both can treat mental illness with psychological treatments, the talking therapies.
Training: medical school first, or a six-year psychology sequence
A psychiatrist starts out as a doctor. RANZCP's Your Health in Mind describes psychiatrists as medical doctors with at least 11 years of training, usually more: a medical degree at university, then at least 1 or 2 years training as a general doctor, then at least 5 years training in the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness. RANZCP's own training pages give the entry requirements in more detail. A trainee needs a medical degree and a minimum of 24 months of general hospital training after it, and the Fellowship program itself takes a minimum of 5 years. On successful completion, a trainee is eligible to become a Fellow of the RANZCP, which is what the letters FRANZCP after a psychiatrist's name refer to.
A psychologist doesn't go through medical school. The Psychology Board of Australia says that to become eligible for general registration, a psychologist completes a six-year sequence of education and training, typically a four-year Board-approved accredited sequence of study in psychology followed by a further two years of Board-approved education and training. The Australian Psychological Society puts the floor the same way, as a minimum of six years of university training. A psychologist with a doctorate can call themselves Dr, but as RANZCP's page notes, that doesn't make them a medical doctor.
What each one does in a session
WorkCover Queensland's own worker guide, Mental health treatment options, gives each profession a short description. It says psychologists are qualified professionals who treat mental health conditions, and will usually work with you to understand your injury and circumstances, then use evidence-based therapies and interventions to support your recovery. It describes a psychiatrist as a medical doctor specialising in mental health conditions, who can diagnose conditions, conduct clinical assessments, prescribe medications and provide psychotherapy.
RANZCP's list of what a psychiatrist can provide goes beyond talking therapy: medication, general medical care including checking your physical health and the effects of medication, psychological treatments, and brain stimulation therapies such as electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). Because they are doctors, it says, psychiatrists understand the links between mental and physical problems. On the psychology side, the Australian Psychological Society names Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Interpersonal Therapy as some common approaches, and says most psychologists are trained in a wide range of modalities that they tailor into an individualised treatment plan.
Medication is the clearest line, but a psychiatrist isn't the only prescriber
RANZCP puts it plainly: psychiatrists prescribe medication, psychologists can't. That doesn't make a psychiatrist the only route to a prescription. WorkCover Queensland's guide says your GP or psychiatrist may prescribe medication such as antidepressants, and that certain medications can only be prescribed by a psychiatrist. Its advice if you're unsure is to speak to your doctor.
Which conditions each one tends to see
RANZCP says psychiatrists tend to treat people who need their medical, psychological and social needs considered, usually people with complex conditions, and gives severe depression, schizophrenia and bipolar disorder as examples. Someone who has attempted suicide or has suicidal thoughts will usually be seen by a psychiatrist, RANZCP says. Psychologists, it says, are more likely to see people with conditions that can be helped effectively with psychological treatments, which might include behavioural problems, learning difficulties, depression and anxiety. Depression shows up on the psychologist list too; RANZCP's psychiatrist example is specifically severe depression.
WorkCover Queensland's guide frames it in similar terms: you're most likely to see a psychiatrist if you have a complex mental health condition, or if you're not responding to other treatment.
Getting an appointment: RANZCP's general referral rule
As a general statement about the two professions, RANZCP says that, as with all medical specialists, to see a psychiatrist you need a referral from your GP, and to see a psychologist you don't need a referral. That is RANZCP describing how the professions work in general. It isn't a description of how referrals work inside a WorkCover Queensland claim, which the GP referral and work capacity certificate guide covers from WorkCover Queensland's own guidance.
It doesn't have to be one or the other
RANZCP says psychiatrists and psychologists often work together, and that a psychiatrist might make an initial assessment and diagnosis, then refer you to a psychologist for ongoing psychological treatment. Some people, it says, might see both. If you're unsure which one you should be seeing, its advice is to talk to your GP, who can give you advice about whether a psychiatrist or a psychologist is right for you. That depends on your own situation and the type of treatment you need.
Checking either one's registration
RANZCP describes psychiatrists as specialist medical doctors who are experts in mental health. The Psychology Board of Australia says general registration allows a psychologist to use the title Psychologist. WorkCover Queensland's guide gives one practical step: look up the registration of any GP, psychologist or psychiatrist on the AHPRA website. Choosing a psychologist for a WorkCover claim covers what to look for on a psychologist's record once you're there.
What this guide doesn't cover
This compares the two professions using RANZCP, the Psychology Board of Australia, the Australian Psychological Society and WorkCover Queensland's own worker guide. It doesn't tell you whether WorkCover Queensland will fund or approve treatment with either one in your claim, or how many sessions, or how long anything takes. What early treatment covers and what it doesn't is where this site deals with that. None of this is medical advice, and your GP is the person to ask which professional is right for you.
Where this came from
- RANZCP Your Health in Mind: Psychiatrists and psychologists, what's the difference?.
- RANZCP: Become a psychiatrist.
- RANZCP: About the Fellowship training program.
- RANZCP: Eligibility criteria for the Fellowship program.
- Psychology Board of Australia: General registration.
- Australian Psychological Society: What is psychology?.
- Australian Psychological Society: Seeing a psychologist FAQs.
- WorkCover Queensland: Mental health treatment options guide for workers.